The Maintenance of Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk’s Political Power and the Building of Nationalist Sentiment from the Conflicts between Cambodia and Thailand, 1955-1970

Authors

  • Yingyot Boonchant Faculty of Arts, Silpakorn University
  • Puengthip Kiattisahakul Assistant Professor Dr. in History, Department of History, Faculty of Arts, Silpakorn University

Keywords:

Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk, Sangkum Reastr Niyum, the maintenance of political power, the building of nationalist sentiment, the conflicts in foreign relation between Cambodia and Thailand

Abstract

Objectives: This article studies the connection between the effort of Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk in maintaining his political power during 1955–1970 and the use of a Cambodian–Thai problematic relationship to fuel Cambodian nationalist sentiment. Our main aim is to pinpoint the fact that conflicts in Cambodia–Thai relations provide another dimension upon which the maintenance of political power can be explained, thus adding to the existing state of knowledge wherein Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk’s effort in maintaining his political power that has usually been explained in three ways: namely the use of state security measures to control political opponents, the establishment of Sangkum Reastr Niyum political organization, and the projection of himself as the people’s ally.

Methods: This qualitative research utilized a historical methodology approach, concentrating on primary sources gathered from the National Archives of Thailand (NAT), the National Archives of Cambodia (NAC), and the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). Moreover, original writings of Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk were also extensively consulted. Primary and secondary data obtained were then subjected to critical analysis and the findings were presented in an analytical narrative form.

Results: This study confirms that the nationalist sentiment built upon the Cambodia–Thai conflicts did contribute to the maintenance of Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk’s political power. Even though he was able to control political power from 1955 onward, he still had to face the continuous internal division within his political party, economic and financial instability and corruption, as well as the expansion of communism, which posed a threat to his power. In order to maintain his hold on political power and to divert public interests from those problems, he used  the Cambodia–Thai conflicts to generate nationalist sentiment. He purposely recounted both past and contemporary conflicts to the Cambodian public who had already mistrusted and might already have hated Thailand, further resulting in the creation of Thailand’s image as the “culprit” and “enemy” in the mind of the people. In this way, from time to time, he was able to divert the preoccupation of Cambodian public from internal problems and generate support and sympathy for himself. It is concluded that his exploitation of international conflicts contributed to his ability to maintain political power for as long as fifteen years.  

Application of this study: The results of this study demonstrate that the creation of Thailand as the “culprit” and “enemy” by Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk was an important turning point that reinforced Cambodia–Thai conflicts, making Cambodia’s historically antagonistic attitude towards Thailand more deeply-rooted within the Cambodian society. In this sense, this article provides useful data and explanation for a broader Thai society, especially in the context of foreign relations, educational texts and the dissemination of knowledge through mass media.

Author Biography

Yingyot Boonchant, Faculty of Arts, Silpakorn University

A graduate student in Doctor of Philosophy (History), Faculty of Arts, Silpakorn University.

References

Armstrong, J. P. (1963). Sihanouk Speaks. New York: Walker and Company.

Boonchant, Y. & Kiattisahakul, P. (2022). “Phaenkan Krungthep”: Phaen Khon Lom Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk (1958-1959). [“The Bangkok Plot”: the Plot to Overthrow Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk (1958-1959)]. Journal of Arts and Thai Studies, 44(3), (ARTS-44-3-2022-R09). (In Thai)

Boonsiripunth, M. (2005). Seriphap Nangsuephim Thai. [Liberty of Thai newspaper]. Bangkok: Thammasat University Press. (In Thai)

Chandler, D. P. (1999). The Tragedy of Cambodian History: Politics, War, and Revolution since 1945. Chiang Mai: Silkworm Books.

Chandler, D. P. (2008). A History of Cambodia. 4th ed. Chiang Mai: Silkworm Books.

“Discour de Samdach Norodom Sihanouk Pendant le 7è Congré National.” (1958). NAC. Affairs Politique. Box 313. National Archives of Cambodia. (In French)

“Hetkan Chaidaen Kambuja (3 Mithunayon 2498-10 Kumphaphan 2502).” [Situation at Cambodia Border (June 3, 1955-February 10, 1959)]. (1955-1959). June 3, 1955-February 10, 1959. NAT. MFA. (2) KT 16.3.1.2/13. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Kambuja Khorong Prathet Phueanban Mai Hai Thiphak Asai Kae Son Ngoc Thanh Kap Phuak Khmer Issarak Lae Rueang Prachum Cheracha Kap Fai Kambuja Kiaokap Hetkan Chaidaen.” [Cambodia requested neighboring countries unhelpful Son Ngoc Thanh and Khmer Issarak, and meeting between Thailand and Cambodia about situation in border]. (1959). July 8, 1959-October 15, 1959. NAT. MOI. (1) MT 3.1.2.8/498. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Kan Cheracha Yut Ying Nai Indochin, Kan Prachum Panha Indochin Na Nakhon Geneva, Tuabot Patinya Khong Thi Prachum Kiaokap Panha Indochin Na Nakhon Geneva Kiaokap Panha Indochin.” [Negotiations for a ceasefire in Indochina, the Geneva Conference on Indochina, the Declaration of Geneva on the Indochina Problem]. (1954). February 23, 1954-August 23, 1954. NAT. OPM. (3) SR 0201.9/32. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Kan Long Prachamati Nai Kambuja.” [Cambodian referendum]. (1955). March 1, 1955. NAT. OPM. (3) SR 0201.9/8. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Kan Pongkan Kan Saeksuem Khong Chin Communism Chak Kambuja.” [The prevention of Chinese Communist’s interventions from Cambodia]. (1958-1959). August 1958-January 1959. NAT. MFA. (1) MT 3.1.2.13/13. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Kan Sonthana Rawang Upathut Phu Raksa Ratchakan Sathan Ekakkhraratchathut Na Phnom Penh Kap Upathut Angkrit.” [Conversation between Thailand Chargé d’Affaires to Phnom Penh and U.K. Chargé d’Affaires]. (1960). NAT. MFA. KT 73.7/44.

National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

Kasetsiri. C. (2008). Siamese/Thai Nationalism and Cambodia: A Case Study of the Preah Vihear Temple. Bangkok: The Foundation for the Promotion of Social Sciences and Humanities Textbooks Projects. (In Thai)

Kiernan, B. (1975). The Samlaut Rebellion and Its Aftermath, 1967-70: The Origins of Cambodia’s Liberation Movement, Part II. Australia: Monash University.

Kiernan, B. (1986). How to Pol Pot Came to Power: A History of Communism in Kampuchea, 1930-1975. London: Verso.

Limsaihua, D. (2017). Thai Nationalism and Territorial Dispute: A Comparative Study of the Field Marshal Plaek Phibulsongkram and the Abhisit Vejjajiva Governments. Doctoral Dissertation, Ph.D. in Political Science, Faculty of Political Science, Chulalongkorn University, Thailand. (In Thai)

Munson, F. P. (1968). Area Handbook for Cambodia. Washington, D.C., United State: the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office.

Ngamin, Y. (2009). World Politics and State Building of Cambodia by King Norodom Sihanouk in 1953-1970. Thesis, M.A. in Southeast Asian Studies (Interdisciplinary Program), Chulalongkorn University, Thailand.

“Nangsuephim Khong Kambuja Long Botkhwam Kiaokap Prathet Thai.” [Cambodia’s newspapers published articles about Thailand]. (1956). March 16, 1956. NAT. MFA. KT 80/62. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Organization and Functioning of the National Assembly of Cambodia 1946-1991.” (1997). NAC. Affairs Politique. Box 109. National Archives of Cambodia. (In Khmer)

Osborne, M. (1966). History and Kingship in Contemporary Cambodia. Journal of Southeast Asian History, 7(1), 1-14.

Phim Phuea Pen Anuson Nai Ngan Phraratchathan Phloengsop Pol.Gen. Chamras Mandukananda Na Men Luang Na Phlapphla Isariyabhorn Wat Debsirindrawas Wan Pharuehatsabodi Thi 23 Minakhom 2501. [This book printed in commemoration of the royal cremation ceremony for Pol.Gen. Chamras Mandukananda at Men Luang Na Phlapphla Isariyabhorn, Wat Debsirindrawas, Bangkok on March 23, 1978]. (1978). Bangkok: Mit Charoen Kan Phim. (In Thai)

Preah Vinaiya Dhamma (Ouch). (1939). Dhamma Desana of Preah Vinaiya Dhamma (Ouch) Wat Pathum Wadi. Kambuja Suriya 11 (10-12), 95-105. (In Khmer)

“Raingan Hetkan Lae Sathanakan Thang Kan Mueang Nai Prathet Kambuja (25 Mesayon-18 Singhakhom 2501).” [Political and Situation at Cambodia Report (April 25, 1958-August 18, 1958)]. (1958). April 25, 1958-August 18, 1958. NAT. OPM. (1) MT 3.1.2.13/50. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Raingan Kan Mueang Dan Kambuja (27 Kanyayon-24 Mithunayon 2503).” [Political Cambodia Report (February 11, 1960-June 24, 1960)]. (1960). Mar 31, 1960. NAT. OPM. (1) MT 3.1.2.13/51. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Raingan Kan Mueang Dan Kambuja (27 Thanwakhom 2502-11 Phruetsaphakhom 2503).” [Political Cambodia Report (December 29, 1959-Mar 11, 1960)]. (1960). April 26, 1960. NAT. OPM. (1) MT 3.1.4.12/9. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Raingan Kan Mueang Lae Rueangrao Tang Tang Nai Kambuja Pi 2500.” [Political and Situation at Cambodia in 1957 Report]. (1957). August 2, 1957-January 8, 1958. NAT. MFA. (2) KT 16.3.1.1/4. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Raingan Kan Mueang Lae Rueangrao Tang Tang Nai Prathet Kambuja Pi 2497.” [Political and Situation at Cambodia in 1954 Report]. (1954). January 12-November 9, 1954. NAT. MFA. (2) KT 16.3.1.1/1. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Raingan Kan Mueang Lae Rueangrao Tang Tang Nai Prathet Kambuja Pi 2498.” [Political and Situation at Cambodia in 1955 Report]. (1955). January 23, 1955-October 26, 1955. NAT. MFA. (2) KT 16.3.1.1/2. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Raingan Kan Mueang Lae Rueangrao Tang Tang Nai Ratchaanachak Kambuja (27 Kanyayon 2494-22 Tulakhom 2496).” [Political and Situation at the Kingdom of Cambodia Report (September 27, 1951-October 22, 1953)]. (1951-1953). September 27, 1951-October 22, 1953. NAT. MFA. (2) KT 3.6.9.2/6. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Raingan Sathanakan Dan Kan Mueang Khong Prathet Kambuja Pi 2501.” [Political and Situation at Cambodia in 1958 Report]. (1958). July 27, 1957-January 8, 1958. NAT. MFA. (2) KT 16.3.1.1/3. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

“Report-Prince Sihanouk and the New Order in Southeast Asia.” (Approved for Release: May 2007)” (n.d.). CIA. The CAESAR, POLO, and ESAU Papers. 5077054e993247d4d82b6ab0. Central Intelligence Agency. [https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/document/5077054e993247d4d82b6ab0]

Sakou, S. (2013). History of Cambodia and Khmer Elites. Cambodia: Angkor. (In Khmer)

Satawedin, D. (1972). Thai-Cambodian Relations for 1953 to 1961. Thesis, M.Pol.Sc., Department of International Relations, Chulalongkorn University, Thailand. (In Thai)

Sihanouk, N. (1958). “Preah Bat Samdech Preah Norodom.” NAC. Affairs Politique. Box 318. National Archives of Cambodia. (In Khmer)

Sihanouk, N. (1975). Indochin Thatsana Chak Pakking Norodom Sihanouk. [L’ Indochine vue de Pékin, entreriens avec Jean Lacouture], Translated by Sawang Wongpuapan. Bangkok: Praphansarn. (In Thai)

Smith, R. M. (1967). Prince Norodom Sihanouk of Cambodia. Asian Survey, 7(6), 353-362.

“Song Samnao Mati Khanakammakan Raksakan Klang Kiaokap Rueang Pharuetikan Tamruat Chaidaen Thai Nai Kan Patibat To Khmer Issarak.” [Central Security Committee’s copies of documents relating to border patrol police’s conduct toward Khmer Issarak]. (1951). June 28, 1951-July 23, 1951. NAT. MFA. (2) KT 3.6.9.2/4. National Archives of Thailand. (In Thai)

Tanadhana, B. (1976). The Study of Prince Sihanouk’s Regime. Thesis, M.Pol.Sc., Department of Government, Graduate School, Chulalongkorn University, Thailand. (In Thai)

Thoeurn, B. (2006). History of Cambodia. Cambodia: Royal Society of Cambodia. (In Khmer)

Vickery, M. (1982). Looking Back at Cambodia, 1942-76. In Edited by Kiernan, B. and Boua, C., Peasants and Politics in Kampuchea 1942-1981, pp.89-113. New York: M.E. Sharpe.

Downloads

Published

29-08-2023

How to Cite

Boonchant, Y., & Kiattisahakul, P. (2023). The Maintenance of Samdech Preah Upayuvareach Norodom Sihanouk’s Political Power and the Building of Nationalist Sentiment from the Conflicts between Cambodia and Thailand, 1955-1970. Journal of Arts and Thai Studies, 45(2), E1719. Retrieved from https://so08.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/artssu/article/view/1719

Issue

Section

Research Articles