Islamophobia as Represented by Thai Buddhist Organizations

Authors

  • Jesada Buaban Indonesian Consortium for Religious Studies, Universitas Gadjah Mada

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61462/cujss.v50i2.705

Keywords:

Islamophobia, separatism, secularism, southern Thailand

Abstract

Scholarly works on Islamophobia in Thailand always focus on the state’s marginalization of Islam in Thai historiography and ultimately makes Muslims become strangers. I argue that the negative labeling of Islam has not only been adopted by the Thai state to support its militarization in the three southern provinces, but is also reproduced by conservative Buddhists to seek supports from the government and Buddhist followers themselves. Therefore, Islamophobia in Thailand cannot be understood without scrutinizing Buddhist groups who reproduce hatred and anti-Islam campaigns. This phenomenon occurs under the condition that the Thai state fails to promote secularism. While the government chooses to assimilate and satisfy Muslims with many projects in order to avoid giving in to their demands for an autonomous or independent state, Buddhists criticize the government for being biased in serving Islam. Interestingly, justice in the Thai Buddhists’ perspective is not secularism, but to prioritize Buddhism in the state’s identity. This paper also provides the concept of peace in the eyes of institutes of peace studies in Thailand, who work to promote multiculturalism without intensively discussing equality and the secular state.

Downloads

References

Raksamani, Adis Idris. 2019. “The Siamese Concept of Muslims through Mural Paintings.” Manusya Journal of Humanities 22(1): 1-19.

Alisuasaming Channel. 2015. “Prawattisat Mutsalim Thai Lae Khunnang Mutsalim Sayam.” [History of Thai Muslims and Siamese Muslim Nobilities]. YouTube Video, 1:27:07. November 25, 2015. Accessed February 6, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bsZrDJLW_3k. (in Thai)

Amin Lona. 2015. “Phatthanakan Kan Khian Prawattisat Isalam Nai Sangkhom Thai (Yuk Rat Charit – Pho So 2511).” [The Development of Writing on Isalamic History in Thai Society (from Traditional State Era to 1968)]. Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, Thaksin University 10(1): 161-186. (in Thai)

Bakali, Naved. 2016. Islamophobia: Understanding Anti-Muslim Racism through the Lived Experiences of Muslim Youth. Leiden: Brill.

Ben Barakun. 1999. Poetpong Khabuankan Lom Phut. [Revealing the Movement to Destroying Buddhism]. Bangkok: Siam Business and Printing. (in Thai)

Chaiwat Satha-Anand, ed. 2009. Imagined Land?: The State and Southern Violence in Thailand. Fuchu City, Japan: Research Institute for Languages and Cultures of Asia and Afrika, Tokyo University of Foreign Studies.

Don Pathan, Ekkarin Tuansiri, and Anwar Koma. 2018. Understanding Anti-Islam Sentiment in Thailand. Translated by Pipob Udomittipong. Pattani: Patani Forum.

BBC. 2017. “Fang Mutsalim Thai Khui Krasae Rawaeng Isalam.” [Listen to Thai Muslims Unearthing Islamophobia]. Accessed February 14, 2019. https://www.bbc.com/thai/thailand-41396198. (in Thai)

-----. 2018. “Ham Nakrian ‘Suam Hiyap’: Raksa Phuenthi Chao Phut Rue Mai Khaorop Muslim?” [Students Prohibited from Wearing Hijab: Preserve the Buddhist Space or No Respect of Muslims?]. Accessed February 14, 2019. www.bbc.com/thai/amp/thailand-44494889. (in Thai)

Gould, Robert. 2016. “Moors and Christians: Fear of Islam in Spanish Political Debates.” In Fear of Muslims?: International Perspectives on Islamophobia, edited by Douglas Pratt, and Rachel Woodlock, 191-211. Basel, Switzerland: Springer.

Hansa Dhammahaso. 2011. Phut Santi Withi: Kan Buranakan Lakkan Lae Khrueangmue Chatkan Khwamkhatyaeng. [Buddhist Approach to Peace: Integrating Principles and Methods in Dealing with Conflict]. Bangkok: 21 Century. (in Thai)

-----. 2016. “Santi Sueksa: Phut Withi Su Santiphap Lok.” [Peace Studies: Buddhist Path to World Peace]. Journal of MCU Peace Studies 4(Special):1-9. (in Thai)

Ibrahim Syukri. 1998. Prawattisat Haeng Ratcha-anachak Patani. [History of the Malay Kingdom of Patani]. Pattani: Prince of Songkhla University. (in Thai)

Jerryson, Michael. 2009. “Appropriating a Space for Violence: State Buddhism in Southern Thailand.” Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 40(1): 33-57.

Julispong Chularatana. 2007. “Muslim Communities during the Ayutthaya Period.” Manusya: Journal of Humanities 10(1): 92-94.

Keyes, Charles. 2009. “Muslim ‘Others’ in Buddhist Thailand.” Thammasat Review 13(1): 19-42.

Khaosod. “Toh Silly Fools: To Pom Yiat Khon Wai Ruppan! Phoei Mai Mi Sitthi Wichan Khrai.” [Toh Silly Fools: Retort on Issue of Statue Worship! No One Has Right to Criticize Others]. 2018. Accessed August 4, 2019. https://www.khaosod.co.th/monitor-news/news_924341. (in Thai)

Kriangkrai Honghengseng. 2018. “Dokmai Ngoen Dokmai Thong- Dokmai Bannakan: Chak Sanyalak Haeng Mittraphap Su Phap Tuathaen Amnat Kan Pokkhrong.” [Golden and Silver Flowers-Floral Tributes: From a Symbol of Friendship to a Representation of Governmental Authority]. Journal of Thai Studies 14(2): 29-60. (in Thai)

Kritsana Thaworn, and Phramaha Duangden Thitanano. 2016. “Botbat Kan Soemsang Santiphap Khong Dr. Ambedker Tamlak Phutthasantiwithi.” [The Peace Strengthening Role of Dr. Ambedker according to the Buddhist Peaceful Means]. Journal of MCU Peace Studies 4(Special): 209-219. (in Thai)

Krongchai Hattha. 1998. Pattani Kan Kha Lae Kan Pokkhrong Nai Adit. [Pattani: Trade and Administration in the Past]. Pattani: Prince of Songkhla University, Pattani Campus. (in Thai)

Kumparan. 2018. “Kronologi Kasus Meiliana dari Keluhan Masjid hingga ke Penjara.” [Chronology of Case Study of Meiliana from the Complaints of the Mosque to the Prison]. Accessed February 6, 2019. http://kumparan.com/@kumparannews/kronologi-kasus-meiliana-dari-keluhan-azan-ke-tetangga-sampai-penjara-1535014365090765011. (in Bahasa Indonesia)

Larsson, Goran. 2005. “The Impact of Global Conflicts on Local Contexts: Muslims in Sweden after 9/11–the Rise of Islamophobia, or New Possibilities?” Islam and Christian–Muslim Relations 16(1): 29-42.

McCargo, Duncan. 2009. “The Politics of Buddhist Identity in Thailand's Deep South: The Demise of Civil Religion?” Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 40(1): 11-32.

Nanchanok Wongsamut. 2019. “Lueaktang 2562: Phak Phaendin Tham Chu Nayobai Phutthasatsana Pen Satsana Prachamchat.” [Election 2019: The Land of Dhamma Party Promoting Buddhism as the State Religion]. Accessed March 3, 2019. https://www.bbc.com/thai/thailand-47067093. (in Thai)

Narongrit Arayachaikul. 2016. Naeothang Kan Sang Santiphap Khong Nelson Mandela Tamlak Phutsantiwithi.” [The Way of Peace Building of Nelson Mandela according to Buddhist Peaceful Means]. Journal of MCU Peace Studies 4(Special): 234-242. (in Thai)

Ockey, James. 2011. “Individual Imaginings: The Religio-Nationalist Pilgrimages of Haji Sulong Abdulkadir al-Fatani.” Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 42(1): 89-119.

P.A. Payutto. 2008. Korani Thammakai: Botrian Phuea Kansueksa Phraphutthasatsana Lae Sangsan Sangkhom Thai. [The Case of Dhammakaya: Lessons for Studying Buddhism and Developing Thai Society] (24th ed.). Bangkok: Bodhidharm Society. (in Thai)

-----. 2017. Kasus Dhammakaya: Kajihan untuk Menpelajari Agama Buddha dan Membangun Masyarakat Thai. [The Case of Dhammakaya: Lesson for Studying Buddhism and Wake Up Thai Buddhists]. Translated by Sangha Theravada Indonesia. Tangerang: Yayasan Sammasayambhu. (in Bahasa Indonesia)

Silpa-Mag. 2020. Phrachao Tak Kap Nai Mut (Chakkri Khaek) Thahan Mutsalim Khu Phrathai. [King Taksin and Mr.Mud (Chakkri Khaek), His Trusted Muslim Soldier]. Accessed February 6, 2019. http://silpa-mag.com/culture/article_20986. (in Thai)

Phee Pongpipatthanapan. 2018. Praden Rohingya Kap Pahi Laksut Santi Sueksa. [Case of Rohingya and the Juggler Peace Studies Course]. Accessed February 6, 2018. https://prachatai.com/journal/2018/10/79042. (in Thai)

Prachatai. 2015. “Phramaha Abhichat Lan Mot Wela Prani Chaidaen Tai Phut Aidia Phra Tai 1 Phao 1 Masjid.” [Ven. Aphichat Warned No More Tolerance in Deep South: Proposing an Idea: One Monk Killed One Masjid Burned]. Accessed February 6, 2019. https://prachatai.com/journal/2015/10/62185. (in Thai) Phramaha Abhichat Lan Mot Wela Prani Chaidaen Tai Phut Aidia Phra Tai 1 Phao 1 Masjid

Praiwan Wannabut. 2016. “Ni Khue Tuayang Khong Hetphon.” [This is an Example of Reason]. Facebook Page, May 7, 2016. Accessed March 4, 2019. https://bit.ly/2V1QdKE. (in Thai)

Pratt, Douglas. 2016. “Expressing Fear of Islam: The Swiss Minaret Ban.” In Fear of Muslims?: International Perspectives on Islamophobia, edited by Douglas Pratt, and Rachel Woodlock, 213-230. Basel, Switzerland: Springer.

Samaphan Chao Phut Haeng Prathet Thai. [Thailand Buddhist Federation]. 2019. Facebook Page. Accessed March 6, 2019. https://www.facebook.com/BuddhistsNews. (in Thai)

SIAM1932 [pseud.]. “Ma Ruchak Sun Phithak Phraphutthasatsana Haeng Prathet Thai.” [Let’s Get to Know the Buddhism Protection Center of Thailand]. 2010. OK Nation (blog), January 23, 2010. Accessed February 5, 2019. http://oknation.nationtv.tv/blog/SIAM1932/2010/01/23/entry-1. (in Thai)

Sun Phithak Phraphutthasatsana Haeng Prathet Thai. [The Buddhism Protection Center of Thailand]. 2019. Facebook Page. Accessed February 6, 2019. https://www.facebook.com/ bpct2556/. (in Thai)

Thamrongsak Petchlertanan. 2014. Wathakam Sia Dindaen. [Lost Territory Discourse]. Bangkok: The Foundation of The Promotion of Social Science and Humanities Textbooks Project. (in Thai)

Thanet Aphornsuvan. 2007. Rebellion in Southern Thailand: Contending Histories. Washington, DC: East-West Center; Singapore: ISEAS.

Thithimadee Arphattananon. 2013. “Nueaha Khwam Pen Phahu Watthanatham Nai Baep Rian Thai.” [Multicultural Content in Thai Textbooks]. Journal of Mekong Societies 9(1): 107-130. (in Thai)

Thongchai Winichakul. 2015. “Buddhist Apologetics and a Genealogy of Comparative Religion in Siam.” Numen: International Review for the History of Religions 62(1): 76-99.

Tuen Thoet Chao Phut. [Wake Up Buddhists]. 2019. Facebook Page. Accessed February 10, 2019. https://bit.ly/2HpWevT. (in Thai)

Weerapot Phonjun, Khanthong Wattanapradithand, and Poonsuk Masrungson. 2018. “Kan Mi Suanruam Khong Satri Chao Phut Nai Kan Soemsang Chumchon Santisuk Nai Changwat Chaidaen Phaktai: Korani Sueksa Chumchon Bannok Tambon Bannok Amphoe Panare Changwat Pattani.” [Buddhist Women’s Participation in Contributing to Promoting Peaceful Communities in Southern Thailand: A case study of Bannok Village, Panare, Pattani]. Journal of MCU Peace Studies 6(special): 76-90. (in Thai)

Wright, Stephanie. 2016. “Reproducing Fear: Islamophobia in the United States.” In Fear of Muslims? International Perspectives on Islamophobia, edited by Douglas Pratt and Rachel Woodlock, 45-66. Basel, Switzerland: Springer.

Yusoh Bunga. 2015. “Botbat Khong Mahawitthayalai Fatoni Nai Kan Sang Santiphap Nai Sam Changwat Chaidaen Phaktai.” [Role of Fatoni University in Building Peace in the Three Southern Border Provinces]. Master’s thesis, Islamic Studies, Prince of Songkla University. (in Thai)

Downloads

Published

07-09-2022

How to Cite

Buaban, Jesada. 2022. “Islamophobia as Represented by Thai Buddhist Organizations”. Chulalongkorn University Journal of Social Sciences 50 (2). Bangkok, Thailand:125-48. https://doi.org/10.61462/cujss.v50i2.705.

Issue

Section

Research Articles