The Dynamics of Change: the Decline and Revival of the Anti-Thaksin Movement

Authors

  • Kanokrat Lertchoosakul Faculty of Political Science, Chulalongkorn University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61462/cujss.v49i1.734

Abstract

This article analyses the dynamics of change within the movement against former Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra. It focuses on its decline under the People's Alliance for Democracy (PAD) and revival under the new movement organization, the People's Democratic Reform Committee (PDRC). It asks questions of what conditions affected the conflict and decline of the anti-Thaksin movement under the PAD; and what major factors caused the successful revival of the anti-Thaksin movement under the PDRC. In responding to these questions, interviews of 100 anti-Thaksin informants from 13 provinces in different regions of Thailand were conducted. It argues that three dimensions of conflict brought about the fragmentation and decline of the anti-Thaksin movement under the PAD: conflict between liberal and ultra conservative forces within the movement; battles between the PAD and the Democrat Party; and internal disagreements within the movement over the New Politics Party. The revival of the anti-Thaksin movement was the result of official dissolution of the PAD as the movement’s organization, the role of the Democrat Party in supporting the PDRC, public pressure over the attempt to pass the amnesty bill for Thaksin, the new ‘loose and pluralistic structure’ of the movement and its ‘inclusive’ strategy to diminish the earlier fragmentation, and making the movement appear less of a political one in order to attract the apolitical middle class and younger generation.

Downloads

References

“AFP Rai-ngan Kanklapma Khong ‘Khon Suea Lueang’.” [AFP Report on the Return of the ‘Yellow Shirts’]. 2011. Manager Online, January 30. Accessed January 21, 2016. http://www2. manager.co. th/Politics/ ViewNews.aspx?NewsID=9540000012914. (in Thai)

Ammar Siamwalla, and Somchai Jitsuchon. 2012. "The Socio-Economic Bases of the Red/Yellow Divide: A Statistical Analysis." In Bangkok May 2010: Perspectives on a Divided Thailand, edited by Michael J. Montesano, Pavin Chachavalpongpun and Aekapol Chongvilaivan, 64-71. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.

“Anti-Government Movement: White Mask Rallies Spread.” Nation, June 17, 2013. Accessed February 22, 2006. http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/White-mask-rallies-spread-30208468.html.

Apichart Satitniramai, Niti Pawakapan, and Yukti Mukdawijitra. 2012. Khrongkan Wichai Thopthuan Phumithat Kanmueang Thai. [Re-examining the Political Landscape of Thailand]. Bangkok: Thai Universities for Healthy Public Policies. (in Thai)

Arthit Suriyawongkul, and Arjin Thongyookong. 2017. Kan Ruam Sang Attalak ‘Khon Di’ Doi Muan Maha Prachachon : Korani Sueksa Sue Suan Bukkhon. [The “Great Mass” and the “Good Man”: Personal Media and Political Identity Coproduction]. Bangkok: National Policies and International Relations Division, The Thailand Research Fund (TRF). (in Thai)

Askew, Marc. 2010. "Confrontation and Crisis in Thailand, 2008-2010." In Legitimacy Crisis in Thailand, edited by Marc Askew, 31-82. Chiang Mai: Silkworm Books.

Asma Wangkulam. 2010. “Botbat Thang Kanmueang Khong Chonchanklang Thai Nai Khabuankan Phanthamit Prachachon Phuea Prachathippatai Phaitai Rabop Thaksin.” [Political Roles of Thai Middle Classes in People’s Alliance for Democracy (PAD) under Thaksin’s Regime]. Master’s thesis, Department of Government, Faculty of Political Science, Chulalongkorn University. (in Thai)

Brown, Andrew, and Kevin Hewison. 2005. "’Economics is the Deciding Facto’: Labour Politics in Thaksin's Thailand." Pacific Affairs 78 (3):353-375.

Chairat Charoensin-o-larn. 2012. "A New Politics of Desire and Disintegration in Thailand." In Bangkok, May 2010: Perspectives on a Divided Thailand, edited by Michael J. Montesano, Pavin Chachavalpongpun and Aekapol Chongvilaivan, 87-96. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.

“Chaiwat-Bannawit Khid Kanyai 13 Siam Thai Thiwi Ni Phuea Khrai.” [Chiwat Bannawit Thinks Big to Establish the 13 Siam Thai TV Channel. Who Is It for?]. 2011. Manager Online, January 21. Accessed January 17, 2016. http://www.manager.co.th/Daily/ViewNews.aspx? NewsID= 9540000009093. (in Thai)

“Chak Yuet Samnak Ngoppraman Su ‘Sunratchakan’ Patibatkan ‘Thueak’ Dapkhrueangchon Lun ‘Kam Chai’ Nuea Ratthaban Pu.” [From Seizing Budget Bureau to Occupying Government Center. Operation ‘Suthep’ on All-or-Never Course to ‘Grab Victory’ over Yingluck Government]. 2013. Matichon Weekly, 34(1737): 10. (in Thai)

“Chaona Phichit Roem Prasan Muanchon Thuk Klum Radom Khon Mun Khao Krung Thuang Ngoen Chamnam Khao Ruam Wethi Ko Po Po So.” [Farmers from Pichit Start to Organise and Take Turns to Join PDRC Protest in Bangkok in Calling for Money from the Rice Pledging Programme]. 2014. Manager Online, February 16. Accessed July 10, 2017. http://www. manager.co.th/local/ViewNews .aspx?NewsID= 9570000018325. (in Thai)

“Charas Chi Oo Po Tho Titkhat Kan Krachai Amnat Phoei Ko Po Po So Triam Poet Naeothang Patirup Reo Reo Ni.” [Charas Shows Department of Local Administration (DLA) Blocking Decentralization, Reveals PDRC Ready to Announce Reform Policy Soon]. 2014. Matichon Online, October 10. Accessed July 8, 2560. http://m.matichon.co.th/readnews.php?newsid= 1412917233. (in Thai)

Connors, Michael K. 2008. "Thailand-Four Elections and a Coup." Australian Journal of International Affairs 62(4):478-496. doi: 10.1080/10357710802480717.

“Dara Ruam Chumnum Pit Krungthep 15 Makarakhom 57 Mi Khrai Bang Pai Du Kan.” [Stars Join the ‘Shut Down Bangkok’ Protest on 15 January 2014. Let’s See Who They Are]. 2014. Kapook.com, January 15. Accessed February 23, 2017. https://women.kapook.com/view 80311.html. (in Thai)

Hataikarn Treesuwan, and Nipawan Keawrakmook. 2014. "7 Wethi Ko Po Po So Chai Nak Kwa 10 Lan to Wan.” [7 Methods of PDRC Cost More Than 10 Million Baht/Day]. Bangkokbiznews, January 20. Accessed February 23, 2016. http://www.bangkokbiznews.com/news/detail/ 557090. (in Thai)

Head, Jonathan. 2013. "Thai PM Yingluck Dissolves Parliament and Calls Election." BBC, December, 9. Accessed March 13, 2016. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-25252795.

Hewison, Kevin. 2008. "A Book, the King and the 2006 Coup." Journal of Contemporary Asia 38(1):190-211.

Ivarsson, Soren, and Lotte Isager, eds. 2010. Saying the Unsayable : Monarchy and Democracy in Thailand. Hawaii : University of Hawaii Press.

Ji Giles Ungpakorn. 2009. "Class Struggle between the Coloured T-Shirts in Thailand." Journal of Asia Pacific Studies 1(1):76 100.

Ji Giles Ungpakorn, and Kengkij Kitirianglarp. 2006. "Kanmueang Khong Phak Prachachon Nai Yuk Phanthamit Prachachon Phuea Prachathippatai Lae Wikrit Lai Thaksin.” [People Sector Politics in the Age of the PAD and the Anti-Thaksin Crisis]. In Khabuankan Khlueanwai Thang Sangkhom Nai Thai. [Social Movements in Thailand], edited by Ji Giles Ungpakorn, 295-330. Bangkok: Labour Democracy. (in Thai)

“Kanlueaktang Yang Mai Chop Ya Phoeng Nap Sop Chang Lom Chapta Aphinihan Sanratthathammanun.” [The Election Is Not Finished, Don’t Count the Number of Fallen Elephants, Keep Eyes on Miracle of Constitutional Court]. 2014. Matichon Weekly, 34(1747): 9. (in Thai)

Kasian Tejapira. 2006. "Toppling Thaksin." New Left Review 39: 5-37.

Kasit, Piromya. 2012. "Thailand’s Rocky Path towards a Full-Fledged Democracy." In Bangkok, May 2010 : Perspectives on a Divided Thailand, edited by Michael J. Montesano, Pavin Chachavalpongpun and Aekapol Chongvilaivan, 161-170. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.

“Ko Po Po So Chi Muanchon 22 Thanwakhom Ruam 6 Lan To Khao Ma Kan Blaeklit 14 Kaennam.” [PDRC Claimed 6 Million Demonstrators on 22 December and Denied the News that Its 14 Leaders Were Blacklisted by the US]. 2013. Manager Daily, December 23. Accessed February 21, 2016. http://www.senate.go.th/w3c/senate/pictures/comm/massmedia/2556/ dec/24/manager.pdf. (in Thai).

“Ko Po Po So Yala Taekkho! Baeng Klum Yaengching Muanchon Tae Mi Udomkan Diaokan ‘Lai Pu-Lom Rabop Thaksin’.” [PDRC Broke Up! Divided in Fight for Mass Support but Still Have Objective in Common to ‘Get Rid of Yingluck – Overthrow Thaksin Regime’]. 2013. Manager Online, December 22. Accessed February 21, 2016. http://www.manager.co.th/South/ ViewNews.aspx?NewsID= 9560000156950. (in Thai)

“Ko Po Tho Yan Paklak 'Saphan Phan Fa' Yok Radap Khon Rabop 'Thaksin'.” [Anti-Thaksin People’s Army Insists on Staying at Phan Fa Bridge, Cranks up Elimination of Thaksin System]. 2013. Thairat Online, November 6. Accessed July13, 2017. https://www.thairath.co. th/content/380905. (in Thai)

“Krasae Nap Thoilang Khong ‘Mop’ Saraphat ‘Klum’ Roem Chak 11 Phruetsachikayon.” [Count Down to ‘Mob’ of Various ‘Groups’ from 11 November]. 2013. Matichon Weekly, 34(1735): 8. (in Thai)

McCargo, Duncan. 2005. "Network Monarchy and Legitimacy Crises in Thailand." The Pacific Review 18(4): 499-519. doi: 10.1080/09512740500338937.

-----. 2009. "Thai Politics as Reality TV." The Journal of Asian Studies 68(1): 7-19. doi: 10.1017/S0021911809000072.

Montesano, Michael J. 2009. "Political Contests in the Advent of Bangkok's 19 September Putsch." In Divided over Thaksin: Thailand’s Coup and Problematic Transition, edited by John Funston, 1-26. Chiang Mai: Silkworm Books.

Montesano, Michael J., Pavin Chachavalpongpun, and Aekapol Chongvilaivan, eds. 2012. Bangkok, May 2010: Perspectives on a Divided Thailand. Singapore : Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.

Morell, David, and Chai-anan Samudavanija. 1981. Politcal Conflict in Thailand : Reform, Reaction, Revolution. Cambridge, MASS: Oelgeschlager, Gunn & Hain.

“Multi-colour Group Gather to Support Govt, Troops.” 2010. Bangkok Post, April 16. Accessed 22 April 2016. http://www.bangkokpost.com/archive/multi-colour-group-gather-to-support-govt-troops/174886.

Nithi Eawsriwong. 2010. “Nithi Eawsriwong: Suea Lueang Pen Khrai Lae Ok Ma Thammai.” [Nithi Eawsriwong: Who Are the Yellow Shirts and Why Did They Start Their Campaign?]. Prachatai, July 13. Accessed January 3, 2013. http://prachatai.com/journal/2010/07/30301. (in Thai)

Nithithorn Lamlueo, and Chana Phasuksakul. 2014. Rongthao Phabai Kap Chai Thueng..Thueng . [Trainer Shoes and Courageous Hearts]. Bangkok: Baan Phra-Arthit. (in Thai)

Nostitz, Nick. 2012. Red vs. Yellow: Volume 1 Thailand's Crisis of Identity. Bangkok: White Lotus Press.

“Nuek Cha Ok Pai ‘Khang Thanon’ Ko Ok Muea Phom Mai Ok Pai Duai Ko Da.” [(They) Protest ‘on the Streets’, Whenever They Want. When I Don’t Join, They Condemn Me]. 2013. Matichon Weekly, 33(1723): 9. (in Thai)

“Pai ‘Sat Sapha’ Khae Phit Khanat Ko Ko To Om-aem Po Tho Mo Chi Krungthep Chong Lueak Patibat.” [‘Parliamentary Animal’ Billboard Only Wrong Size - Election Commission of Thailand (ECT) Hesitant – PAD Accuses Bangkok Metropolitan Administration (BMA) of Double Standard]. 2011. Manager Online, June10. Accessed February 24, 2016. http://www. manager.co.th/daily/ViewNews.aspx?NewsID= 9540000070786. (in Thai)

Panitan Pichalai. 2012. “Kan Tosu Thang Kanmueang Khong Klum Phanthamit Prachachon Phuea Prachathippatai Nai Samai Ratthaban Thaksin Shinawatra.” [Strategies for Political Struggles of the People’s Alliance for Democracy during Thaksin’s Government]. PhD diss., Faculty of Political Science, Chulalongkorn University. (in Thai)

Pasuk Phongpaichit, and Chris Baker. 2008. "Thaksin's Populism." Journal of Contemporary Asia 38(1): 62-83.

“Phanthamit Roem Taek! Somsak At Sonthi Saeksaeng Phak.” [PAD Starts to Break up! Somsak Criticizes Sondhi for Intervening in Parties]. 2011. MThai, May 1. Accessed February 24, 2016. https://news.mthai.com/politics-news/112145.html. (in Thai)

Pittaya Wongkul. 2008. Lak Khit Lae Botrian Yutthasat Prachachon. [Principles of Thought and Lessons from People Strategy]. Bangkok: Choomsil-thammada. (in Thai)

Pongpipat Banchanon. 2013. "Yon Adit Wiwatha Pom ‘Nayok Mattra 7’ Kon ‘Suthep’ Pat Fun Sanoe Mai.” [Retrospective Debate on ‘Article 7 PM ’ before ‘Suthep’ Dusts off New Proposal]. Isranews Agency, December 4. Accessed July 10, 2017. https://www.isranews.org/isranews-scoop/item/25640-article7.html. (in Thai)

“Phanthamit Prachachon Phuea Prachathippatai Thalaeng Yuti Botbat Thang Kanmueang.” [PAD Announced Termination of Their Political Roles]. 2013. Prachatai, August 23. Accessed April 2, 2016. http://www.prachatai.com/journal/2013/08/48371. (in Thai)

Pye, Oliver, and Wolfram Schaffar. 2008. "The 2006 Anti-Thaksin Movement in Thailand: An Analysis." Journal of Contemporary Asia 38(1): 38-61.

Sinpeng, Aim. 2012. "Pitak Siam’s Failure." New Mandala, November 26. Accessed February 22, 2016. http://asiapacific.anu.edu.au/newmandala/2012/11/26/pitak-siams-failure.

“Sinthia Rong Sop Nueaha ‘Top Chot’ Lamoet Sathaban-‘Klum Prachachon Thon Mai Wai’ Nat Chumnum Phrungni.” [‘Sinthia’ Demands Answer about ‘Answering Question’ Programme Violating the Royal Institution – People’s Group Schedules Protest for Tomorrow]. 2013. Manager, March 19. Accessed March 17, 2016. http://www.manager.co.th/Politics/ ViewNews.aspx?NewsID=9560000033571. (in Thai)

“’Somsak’ Poet Sun Phak Ko Mo Mo Khorat Chuenmuen-Prachachon Nakrop Mue Top Ruam Nueangnaen.” [‘Somsak’ Opens the Party’s Branch. Committee Happy – A Lot of Hand-Clapping People Joined the Event]. 2009. Manager Daily Online, August 10. Accessed February 21, 2016. https://mgronline.com/local/detail/9520000090638. (in Thai)

Stent, James. 2012. "Thoughts on Thailands Turmoil, 11 June 2010." In Bangkok, May 2010: Perspectives on a Divided Thailand, edited by Michael J. Montesano, Pavin Chachavalpongpun and Aekapol Chongvilaivan, 15-41. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.

“Suthep Poet Wong Thok Patirup Krachai Amnat Lot Botbat Rat.” [Suthep Starts Debate on Decentralization Reform, Reduce state role]. 2014. Thairat Online, March 14. Accessed July12, 2017. https://www. thairath.co.th/content/409907. (in Thai)

Thai Thon. 2013. "Ratthaban Yingluck Cha Lang Phit Thaksin Duai Phraratchabanyat Nirathotkam…Cha Tham Phuea Prachachon Rue Phuea Ton-eng Kan Nae?” [Yingluck Government Whitewashes Thaksin with the Amnesty Bill … for People or for Themselves?]. Manager Online, October 21. Accessed February 22, 2016. http://www.manager.co.th/ daily/ViewNews.aspx?NewsID=9560000131887.(in Thai)

Thirayuth Boonmee. 2006. “Thirayut Chi Thaksin Phayayam Lom Thruesadi Song Nakhara Prachathippatai.” [Thirayuth Points Thaksin Attempts to Dissolve the Two Tales of Democracy Theory]. Krungthep Turakij, 15 January 6. (in Thai)

Thongchai Winichakul. 2008. "Toppling Democracy." Journal of Contemporary Asia 38(1): 11-37.

“Thueak Tang Ko Po Po So Phadet Suek ‘Rabop Maeo’ 1 Thanwakhom Wan Haeng Chai-Yuet Sunratchakan Betset Tangtae Khuen Ni Kon Ruk Khuep Yuet Thamniap So To Cho.” [Suthep Tueksuhbhan to Finish off ‘Thaksin Regime’ from Tonight. 1st December, the Day of Victory-Complete Occupation of Government Offices Center before Moving to Occupy Government House and Police Headquarters]. 2013. Manager Daily, November 29. (in Thai)

“Truat Thaeo Mop Lom Ratthaban Siang Nokwit Chak Po Cho Po Kanmueang Tae ‘Chutdueat'.” [Check Strength of Anti-Government Mob. Sound of Whistles from Democrat Party. Politics Reaches ‘Boiling Point’]. 2013. Matichon Weekly, 34(1732): 10. (in Thai)

Ukrist Pathmanand. 2008. "A Different Coup d'État?" Journal of Contemporary Asia 38(1): 124-142.

“Yon Chom ‘Nangfa’ Nai Mu Mop Sisan Chat Dao Krungthep.” [Look at ‘Angels’ in the Mob – Colour in the ‘(Bangkok) Shut Down’ Protest]. 2014. Manager Online, January 15. Accessed July 8, 2017. http://www.manager.co.th/daily/viewnews.aspx?NewsID=9570000005514. (in Thai)

“Yutthasat ‘Phadet Suek’ ‘Thep Thueak’ Khum ‘Thanon’ ‘ Mark’ Khum ‘Sapha’ 2 Kha ‘Po Cho Po’ Te Tat Kha Ratthaban ‘Pu’.” [Strategy to ‘Win the War’. Suthep Controls Streets, Abhisit Controls Parliament. 2 Legs of Democrat Party Kick Yingluck Government Asunder]. 2013. Matichon Weekly, 34(1734): 11. (in Thai)

Downloads

Published

14-09-2022

How to Cite

Lertchoosakul, Kanokrat. 2022. “The Dynamics of Change: the Decline and Revival of the Anti-Thaksin Movement”. Chulalongkorn University Journal of Social Sciences 49 (1). Bangkok, Thailand:7-34. https://doi.org/10.61462/cujss.v49i1.734.

Issue

Section

Research Articles